Arrival left you staring at a wall for an hour. Good. These eight hit the same nerve: patient, strange, and smarter than their trailers.
Number one has zero spaceships, zero aliens, and it's still the closest match.
- 8
Prisoners is Villeneuve at his grimmest, and least Arrival.
Same director, same overcast dread, same patience. Swap the aliens for a missing-kid mystery. It made $122 million worldwide, but its 7.6 is the lowest Villeneuve score here.
- 7
The Prestige deserves way better than a 7.4.
Like Arrival, it cares about how a story is told, not just what happens. 1.6 million IMDb voters rate it 8.5. Critics gave it a 66 Metacritic. Critics blinked.
- 6
Donnie Darko is the weird cousin who still gets invited.
Time, dread, and a lonely kid nobody believes. It made $8.6 million worldwide on a reported $4.5 million budget and still pulls an 8.5 movie.guru score.
- 5
Moon does more with one actor than most do with armies.
Quiet sci-fi about isolation and identity, which is Arrival's whole mood. Sam Rockwell carries it on a reported $5 million budget. Its audience score beats 94% of movies.
- 4
Blade Runner 2049 is Arrival with longer silences and more rain.
Same director, same foggy awe, same question of what makes someone human. Reported $150 million budget, $287 million worldwide, and the Guru's Take is a 9.1.
- 3
Contact is Arrival's real parent, and its 7.3 is criminal.
A scientist, a signal from space, and a movie that cares more about belief than lasers. It made $171 million worldwide. Critics gave it a 62 Metacritic. Way too low.
- 2
Incendies is Villeneuve's best movie. Not Arrival. This one.
Same director, same slow unraveling of family and memory. A 9.3 movie.guru score on a reported $6.5 million budget. Go in knowing nothing. Seriously, nothing.
- 1
The Father isn't sci-fi, and it's the closest match here.
No aliens, no ships. Just Anthony Hopkins in a mind where time stops behaving. Grief, memory, a puzzle you live inside. A 9.6 movie.guru score, highest on this list.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least Arrival. Wrong answers only.
$46.71 says you finish The Father and immediately text your dad.
Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link
Current mood: ready to fight about it